Bio-degradable cards

Every card imaginable!

Understanding the Differences Between PNES and Epilepsy

Psychogenic Non-Epileptic Seizures (PNES) and Epilepsy

It can be really confusing when someone has episodes that look like seizures. You see them shaking or staring, and it's natural to think of epilepsy. But there are actually two very different conditions that can cause these kinds of events: Psychogenic Non-Epileptic Seizures (PNES) and epilepsy. While they might look similar from the outside, they come from completely different places in the body and brain.

Think of it this way: imagine two cars that both break down on the side of the road. To an onlooker, they both just look broken. But one might have a flat tire (a physical problem), while the other might have run out of gas (a different kind of problem). You'd fix them in completely different ways, right? It's similar with PNES and epilepsy. Knowing which one someone has is super important because it completely changes how doctors help them and what kind of support they need.

Epilepsy

Let's start with epilepsy. This is a condition that comes directly from the brain. If you think of your brain as a giant, complex electrical system, sometimes things can go a bit haywire. In epilepsy, certain parts of the brain suddenly send out too many electrical signals all at once, like a short circuit. This burst of uncontrolled electrical activity is what we call a seizure.

What a seizure looks like depends on where in the brain these electrical fireworks happen. It could be someone staring blankly, twitching an arm, or even losing consciousness and shaking all over.

Why does this happen? The causes of epilepsy can be varied. Sometimes it's something someone is born with (genetic), other times it might be from an injury to the head, a stroke, a growth in the brain, or even infections that affect the brain.

PNES

Now, let's look at PNES. This is where things get really interesting and often misunderstood. PNES episodes look like epileptic seizures – they can involve shaking, staring, or even collapsing – but they are not caused by electrical problems in the brain. Instead, PNES are a physical way the body reacts to intense psychological stress, difficult past experiences (trauma), or other mental health challenges.

Imagine your body trying to tell you, "Hey, something's really tough to deal with mentally right now!" but instead of just feeling anxious or sad, that distress comes out in a physical way, almost like a seizure. It's not something someone does on purpose; it's an involuntary response, a bit like how some people get a headache when they're stressed, but much more dramatic. PNES falls under a group of conditions called functional neurological disorders, which basically means the brain isn't working quite right in sending messages, even though there's no physical damage to it.

Let's break down how doctors figure out if someone has PNES or epilepsy. This part is super important because getting the right diagnosis is the first step to getting the right help.

Diagnosis

Figuring out whether someone has PNES or epilepsy can be a bit like solving a puzzle. It's really important to get it right, because the treatments are completely different!

Diagnosing Epilepsy

When doctors suspect epilepsy, they typically look at a few key things:

Talking about what happened: First, they'll ask a lot of questions about the episodes themselves. What do they look like? How long do they last? What happens before and after? Getting a detailed "story" of the seizures is really helpful.
EEG (Electroencephalogram): This is a main tool. Think of an EEG as listening in on your brain's electrical conversations. Small sensors are placed on the scalp, and they record the electrical activity. If someone has an epileptic seizure while connected to an EEG, the recording will show very specific, abnormal electrical patterns – like a sudden burst of static or a strange rhythm that shouldn't be there. This is a big clue that it's epilepsy.
Brain Scans (like MRI): Doctors might also order scans like an MRI. This is like taking a detailed picture of the brain itself. They're looking to see if there are any physical reasons for the epilepsy, like an old injury, a small scar, or something else that could be causing those electrical misfires.

Diagnosing PNES

Diagnosing PNES also starts with a very careful look at the person's story and experiences.

Detailed History: Just like with epilepsy, the doctor will want to know everything about the episodes. But they'll also likely ask more about stress, difficult life events, and how the person is feeling emotionally, because these are often connected to PNES.
EEG (The Key Difference!): Here's where the EEG becomes the crucial detective. If someone is having a PNES episode while connected to an EEG, the recording will look normal. This is the absolute biggest difference. Even though the person might be shaking or unresponsive, the brain's electrical activity during a PNES episode won't show those abnormal patterns you'd see in epilepsy. It confirms that the event isn't coming from an electrical storm in the brain.
Video-EEG Monitoring: The Gold Standard: This is often the best way to get a clear diagnosis. The person stays in a special hospital unit for a few days, and they are hooked up to an EEG and a video camera at the same time. This allows the doctors to:
- See the episode: They can watch exactly what happens during an episode.
- Simultaneously check the brain's electricity: While watching the video, they can see the EEG recording. If an episode happens and the EEG stays normal, it provides very strong evidence for PNES. This combination helps doctors confidently say, "This looks like a seizure, but it's not coming from abnormal brain electricity."

Now that we've talked about how doctors figure out what's going on, let's look at how they help people with these conditions. This is where the differences between PNES and epilepsy really shine through, because the treatments are aimed at completely different things.

Treatment

Imagine you have a leaky faucet. If the leak is coming from a loose washer, you fix the washer. But if the leak is because a pipe burst in the wall, you have to fix the pipe. You wouldn't try to fix a burst pipe by tightening a washer, right? It's the same idea with PNES and epilepsy – the treatment has to match the cause.

Treating Epilepsy

Since epilepsy is a neurological condition caused by those abnormal electrical signals in the brain, the treatments focus on calming down that electrical activity.

Anti-Epileptic Drugs (AEDs): These are the main go-to treatment. AEDs are medications specifically designed to stabilize the electrical activity in the brain and prevent seizures. There are many different types of AEDs, and doctors work closely with patients to find the right one (or combination) that controls their seizures with the fewest side effects. It's often a bit of trial and error to get it just right.
Other Options: For some people where medication doesn't work well, or for specific types of epilepsy, other treatments might be considered:
- Surgery: In certain cases, if the seizures are consistently coming from one specific, small area of the brain that can be safely removed, surgery might be an option.
- Dietary Changes: Special diets, like the ketogenic diet, can be helpful for some children and adults with epilepsy when medications aren't enough.
- Nerve Stimulation: Devices that stimulate certain nerves (like the vagus nerve) can sometimes help reduce seizure frequency.

The specific treatment plan for epilepsy always depends on things like what type of epilepsy it is, how often seizures happen, how severe they are, and the person's overall health.

Treating PNES

Because PNES episodes are the body's physical reaction to underlying stress, trauma, or emotional difficulties, the treatment doesn't involve brain medications. Instead, it focuses on helping the person understand and manage those psychological roots.

Talking Therapies (Psychotherapy): This is the cornerstone of PNES treatment. Working with a mental health professional (like a therapist or psychologist) is key. They help individuals:
- Understand the connection: Learn how their emotional states and past experiences might be linked to their PNES episodes.
- Develop coping skills: Find healthier ways to manage stress, anxiety, and other difficult emotions that might be triggering the episodes.
- Process trauma: If past trauma is a factor, therapy can provide a safe space to work through those experiences.
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT): This is a specific type of therapy that is very effective for PNES. CBT helps people identify and change negative thought patterns and behaviors that might be contributing to their distress and, in turn, their PNES episodes. It's about learning new ways to think and react.
Stress Management Techniques: Learning practical ways to handle stress, such as mindfulness, relaxation exercises, or even just finding healthy outlets for feelings, can be very beneficial.
Medication for Mental Health: Sometimes, a doctor might prescribe medication to help with accompanying mental health conditions like anxiety or depression. These aren't to stop the PNES episodes directly, but to treat the underlying conditions that can make PNES worse.

It's really important for someone with PNES to have a team of healthcare professionals, including mental health specialists, working together to provide comprehensive support. This collaborative approach helps address both the physical manifestation of the episodes and the emotional well-being of the person.

Let's talk about what life looks like for people living with epilepsy or PNES, and what they can expect in the future. This is what doctors call "prognosis," and it's also about the broader impact these conditions have on someone's life.

Prognosis and Impact

When someone is diagnosed with either epilepsy or PNES, a natural question is, "What does this mean for my future?" The answer isn't always simple, as it depends a lot on the individual, the specifics of their condition, and how they respond to treatment.

Prognosis and Impact for Epilepsy

For people with epilepsy, the future can look quite different from one person to another.

Seizure Control: Many people with epilepsy can achieve excellent control over their seizures with the right medication. Some even become completely seizure-free, which is fantastic! This allows them to lead full, active lives without the constant worry of when the next seizure might strike.
Ongoing Challenges: However, for others, finding the right treatment can be a long journey, and some may continue to have seizures despite trying different medications and therapies. This can be really frustrating and challenging.
Beyond the Seizures: The impact of epilepsy isn't just about the seizures themselves. Living with epilepsy can affect many parts of life:
- Social Life: There can be misunderstandings from others, or feelings of isolation. Driving restrictions can also limit independence.
- Emotional Well-being: It's common for people with epilepsy to experience anxiety or depression, especially if seizures are frequent or unpredictable.
- Thinking and Memory: Some people might notice difficulties with memory, focus, or other thinking skills, which can impact school or work.

Because of these wider impacts, living with epilepsy often means needing support that goes beyond just stopping seizures. It involves looking at the person as a whole and making sure they have the right medical, emotional, and social support.

Prognosis and Impact for PNES

The outlook for PNES also varies, but with the right kind of help, many people see significant improvement.

Reduction or Stopping Episodes: A very positive outcome is that with good psychological therapy and support, many individuals with PNES experience a big reduction in how often their episodes happen, or even stop having them altogether! This can be incredibly life-changing.
Factors for Success: How well someone does with PNES treatment often depends on a few things:
- Commitment to Therapy: Therapy takes effort and time. The more someone engages with their treatment, the better the chances of success.
- Complexity of Issues: If the underlying psychological factors (like past trauma or severe stress) are very complex, it might take longer and require more intensive therapy.
- Finding the Right Therapist: Connecting with a mental health professional who understands PNES and with whom the person feels comfortable is really important.
Addressing the Roots: The key difference here is that "success" in PNES treatment isn't just about stopping the physical episodes; it's about helping the person manage the underlying emotional pain or stress that caused the episodes in the first place. When those core issues are addressed, the physical manifestations often fade away.
Improved Quality of Life: Even if episodes don't stop completely, learning coping skills and understanding the condition can significantly improve a person's overall quality of life, their ability to manage stress, and their emotional well-being.

Let's wrap up our discussion by looking at some of the tough parts of dealing with these conditions, both for the people experiencing them and for the healthcare system.

Challenges in Understanding and Management

Even though we're learning more and more about epilepsy and PNES, there are still some big hurdles. These challenges can make life even harder for those affected, and they highlight why it's so important for everyone to understand these differences.

The Problem of Stigma and Misunderstanding:
- For Epilepsy: Sadly, there's still a lot of old-fashioned thinking and fear around seizures. People with epilepsy can face misconceptions that lead to them feeling alone, being treated differently at work or school, or even facing discrimination. It's tough when a medical condition causes you to be judged.
- For PNES: This is where it gets particularly difficult. Because PNES episodes come from psychological stress, people sometimes wrongly think the person is "faking" their seizures for attention. This idea is incredibly damaging and unfair. PNES episodes are very real and involuntary, and suggesting someone is faking them adds immense emotional pain to an already challenging situation.
The Dangers of Misdiagnosis:
- One of the most critical challenges is when PNES is mistakenly diagnosed as epilepsy. This can happen, especially if detailed EEG monitoring isn't done.
- Unnecessary Medication: If someone with PNES is thought to have epilepsy, they might be put on anti-epileptic drugs (AEDs). These drugs are not only ineffective for PNES (because there's no electrical brain problem to fix), but they also come with side effects. Taking medication you don't need, that isn't helping, and that makes you feel unwell, is incredibly frustrating and can delay getting the right help.
- The Right Path: On the flip side, when doctors correctly identify PNES and guide patients toward the right psychological support, it can be absolutely life-changing. It means they finally get the tools to address the real root of their episodes, leading to real improvement and a better quality of life.

Bringing it All Together

So, while a seizure might look like a seizure on the surface, we've seen that epilepsy and PNES are fundamentally different at their core. One comes from electrical issues in the brain, the other from profound psychological distress manifesting physically.

Understanding these distinctions isn't just academic; it's absolutely vital for everyone involved:

For Healthcare Professionals: Doctors, nurses, and therapists need to be skilled at recognizing the subtle differences in presentation and using the right diagnostic tools (especially video-EEG) to ensure an accurate diagnosis.
For Patients and Families: Knowing whether it's epilepsy or PNES helps patients and their loved ones understand what's happening, what to expect, and how to best support the journey to recovery.
For Everyone Else: Greater public awareness can help reduce the stigma and misunderstanding that both conditions face, creating a more supportive environment for those affected.

The good news is that as we learn more and share that knowledge, the chances of people getting the right diagnosis and the most effective treatment for both epilepsy and PNES keep getting better. It really highlights why different specialists – like neurologists (brain doctors), psychiatrists and psychologists (mental health specialists), and even your regular family doctor – need to work together as a team. This collaborative approach is the best way to ensure everyone experiencing seizures, no matter the cause, gets the comprehensive care they truly need.

Based in the Lake District, we have been making systems for the design, print and management of ID cards since 2011

Frequently asked questions

Delivery options